The burger scene in Utah Valley is deeper than it looks. Beyond the chains, Provo and Orem have a solid collection of independent burger joints, gourmet options, and old-school drive-in-style spots that take their craft seriously. Whether you want a $5 classic or a $15 gourmet stack, there's a place for you.
The Best Burgers
1. Cubby's
Gourmet Burgers · $$ · Provo
The most complete burger experience in the valley. Cubby's serves thick, stacked burgers with quality ingredients, creative topping combinations, and a menu that goes well beyond the standard cheeseburger. The buns are fresh, the patties are generously sized, and the fry sauce is addictive. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, and the prices are fair for what you get.
What to order: The signature Cubby's burger with fry sauce. The loaded fries are worth adding.
2. Burgers Supreme
Classic Burgers · $ · 1796 N University Ave, Provo
No-frills, old-school burgers done exactly right. Burgers Supreme has been feeding BYU students for years with thick patties, hand-cut fries, and milkshakes that taste like they should cost twice the price. It's not trying to be Instagram-worthy — it's trying to be a really good burger joint. The double cheeseburger with fry sauce is the default order for a reason.
Best for: Budget-conscious students who want a real burger, not fast food.
3. Backdoor BRGR
Smash Burgers · $$ · Provo
Smash-style burgers with crispy, lacy edges and that distinctive Maillard crust that smash burger enthusiasts obsess over. Backdoor BRGR does a few things and does them well — the menu is focused, the execution is consistent, and the burgers have a satisfying crunch-to-juice ratio that thicker patties can't match.
4. Tommy's Burgers
Classic · $ · Provo
Another longtime local favorite serving straightforward, affordable burgers. Tommy's doesn't reinvent anything — it just makes solid, satisfying burgers at prices that won't make you flinch. Good fries, good shakes, and the kind of casual, quick-service experience that works for a weeknight dinner or a quick lunch.
5. Fancy Burger
Gourmet · $$ · Provo
Despite the name, Fancy Burger strikes a middle ground between fast-casual and sit-down. Quality ingredients, creative topping options, and a step above typical burger chains in both presentation and flavor. The menu includes interesting sauce options and premium toppings that justify the slightly higher price point.
6. MOOYAH
Build-Your-Own · $$ · Provo/Orem
A quality national chain that lets you build your burger from the ground up — bun type, patty (beef, turkey, veggie), cheese, toppings, and sauce. The customization is genuinely useful, and the quality sits well above typical fast food. The hand-cut fries and real ice cream shakes round out the experience.
7. JCW's
Classic American · $$ · Multiple Utah Valley locations
A Utah chain known for oversized burgers, creative specialty options, and a retro-diner atmosphere. JCW's portions are enormous — the burgers are thick, the fries are plentiful, and you will not leave hungry. The specialty burgers (with names like The Maui Wowi and The BBQ Bacon) rotate seasonally.
The Budget Pick
Burgers Supreme is the best value in the valley — a solid burger, fries, and a shake for well under $15. For students and budget-conscious eaters, it's the clear winner.
The Gourmet Pick
Cubby's delivers the most complete elevated-burger experience. Quality ingredients, creative combinations, and an atmosphere that works for both a quick lunch and a casual dinner.
The Late-Night Pick
Options are limited after 10 PM in Provo. Fast-food chains (In-N-Out on University Ave in Orem stays open late) are often the only options. Burgers Supreme closes earlier than most people want.
Related Guides
- 25 Best Restaurants in Provo
- Best Restaurants in Orem
- Best Food Near BYU
- Eating on a Student Budget
- Best Pizza in Provo & Orem
Last updated: April 2026.