This is an opinion column. We're from Provo, we watch every snap, and we're saying out loud what a lot of BYU fans are saying today. The numbers are real, the quotes are real, and the sources are at the bottom.
BYU won today. Let's get that out of the way, because the scoreboard says 31-29, the record says 9-2, and in a season where the Cougars have been ranked as high as No. 2, a win is a win.
But nobody in Utah Valley turned off the TV this afternoon feeling good. A 4-7 Kansas team took the No. 10 team in the playoff rankings to three overtimes. BYU led 16-6 in the third quarter and let Kansas score 10 straight to tie it. Matthias Dunn missed a 37-yarder as regulation ran out. The Cougars needed a Kansas fumble in the third overtime and a two-point pass to Jojo Phillips to get out of Lawrence alive.
The Salt Lake Tribune's recap put it gently: the Cougars "probably didn't win over any new believers." Gordon Monson, in the same paper, was less gentle. He wrote that the offense was at times "a mess," "unreliable, mistake-prone, inefficient and ineffective," and that BYU had "scraped by competition that a great team would have blown off the field."
He's right. And if your feed looks like ours this afternoon, a lot of you already said it first.
The quarterback who beat Notre Dame hasn't come back
Five weeks ago, Bear Bachmeier played the best game of his career. Against No. 2 Notre Dame on Oct. 17, he went 23 of 36 for 224 yards by KSL's count, ran for two touchdowns, caught a touchdown pass on a trick play and then drove BYU down the field to throw the winner to Walker Lyons with 1:53 left. BYU jumped to No. 2 in the AP poll. That was a quarterback who looked like he knew exactly what was going to happen before the snap.
Then came Utah. Bachmeier threw for 272 yards, including a 75-yard touchdown to Legend Glasker, and Utah intercepted him four times. The Deseret News called it a career-worst day. BYU lost 28-20 and lost the Holy War streak with it.
Here's what the two games since look like:
| Game | BYU passing yards | Passing TDs | What else |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notre Dame (Oct. 17) | 239 | 2 | Bachmeier: 2 rushing TDs, a TD catch, the winning drive |
| Utah (Nov. 7) | 272 | 1 | 4 interceptions |
| Baylor (Nov. 14) | 123 | 1 | Bachmeier: 3 rushing TDs |
| Kansas (Nov. 21) | 173 | 0 | 3 sacks; Bachmeier fumble before halftime |
Team totals from Sportradar's box scores; the Notre Dame total includes a 15-yard touchdown throw by a receiver.
Look at what's left. Against Baylor and Kansas, BYU threw for 296 yards combined. He's still winning games with his legs: three rushing touchdowns against Baylor, two more today, a fourth-down scramble that set up the touchdown that put BYU up 16-6. But the downfield throws that beat Notre Dame are gone. The AP reported Kansas held him to 68 yards of total offense in the first half. The Tribune noted he "misfired on back-to-back pass attempts" before BYU settled for a field goal.
Our read, and it's an opinion: he's playing like a quarterback who doesn't want to throw the fifth interception. Safe throws, early tuck-and-runs, nothing into a tight window. You can't blame a college quarterback for still feeling Rice-Eccles in his bones. But you can say that this offense isn't a playoff offense when its quarterback won't let it be one.
To be fair to him: his coaches don't see it that way. After Utah, offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick told the Deseret News, "that hasn't diminished our faith in him one bit," and Kalani Sitake called the Utah game "uncharacteristic of what we've seen from Bear." Bachmeier has led BYU to 19 wins in 23 starts going into Baylor. He has earned some patience. He has not earned a free pass on the last two weeks.
Is this a playoff team?
Right now, barely. BYU was No. 10 in the College Football Playoff rankings going into Saturday. The Tribune, citing ESPN's predictor, says BYU's playoff odds go to 85% with a win over Cincinnati next week and drop to 7% with a loss.
But the committee doesn't only count wins. CBS Sports called today's result a "less-than-impressive win at Kansas" and said Wake Forest, which won 50-29 at Georgia Tech, could jump BYU on Tuesday night. Chris Vannini posted the stat that should worry every Cougar fan: six of BYU's last eight games have been decided by one score. That's not a team putting people away. That's a team surviving, and the selection committee knows the difference.
The Big 12 title game is mostly out of BYU's hands. Utah is 11-0 and Texas Tech is 10-1, and both sit ahead of BYU in the standings going into the final weekend.
The part BYU fans really don't want to hear
This is a pattern, and we've now seen it three years running.
- 2024: BYU started 9-0. Then Kansas beat them 17-13 in Provo, Arizona State beat them the next week, and the Cougars missed the Big 12 title game.
- 2025: BYU went 11-1 in the regular season. Then Texas Tech beat them 34-7 in the Big 12 championship game. The Deseret News's own takeaway: "BYU faded fast after a strong start."
- 2026: BYU started 6-0, beat No. 2 Notre Dame and climbed to No. 2. Since then, between wins over Arizona State and Baylor: a double-overtime loss at UCF, a four-interception loss at Utah and a three-overtime escape at 4-7 Kansas.
Shehan Jeyarajah posted today: "I will never understand BYU." Another post the Deseret News collected put it better than we can: "I swear BYU has played the same football game every other week of my life."
Fast start. Big win. National hype. Then a November where every game is a coin flip and the season ends one loss short of where it should. That's the BYU story fans have learned to brace for, and today felt like the first chapter of it all over again.
What would change our minds
One game. Cincinnati comes to LaVell Edwards Stadium on Saturday at 1:30 p.m. If Bachmeier throws the ball the way he did against Notre Dame, and BYU wins by three touchdowns instead of three overtimes, we'll happily write the column that says we panicked. We'd love to write it.
But if it's another one-score game decided by a fumble and a prayer, don't be surprised when the committee says what a lot of BYU fans are already saying: good team, not a playoff team.
Related coverage
- UCF beats No. 2 BYU in double overtime
- BYU stuns No. 2 Notre Dame 28-24
- Utah 28, BYU 20: four interceptions sink the Cougars
- BYU 28, Baylor 7
- BYU at Kansas and the Big 12 title race
- BYU vs. Cincinnati: game week guide
- The Holy War, explained
Frequently Asked Questions
Did BYU beat Kansas in 2026?
What is BYU's record?
How did Bear Bachmeier play against Kansas?
How did Bachmeier play against Utah?
How did Bachmeier play against Notre Dame?
Can BYU still make the College Football Playoff?
When does BYU play next?
Has BYU faded late in recent seasons?
Sources
The facts in this guide were checked against these sources. Hours, fees and rules change, so confirm anything time-sensitive with the source before you go. How we make Provo.com.
- No. 12 BYU beats Kansas 31-29 in 3 OTs to stay alive in College Football Playoff race, Associated Press (via ABC News). Checked November 21, 2026.
- BYU avoids scare, escapes Kansas with triple OT win on the road, KSL.com. Checked November 21, 2026.
- BYU football survives Kansas in triple overtime to keep CFP hopes alive, The Salt Lake Tribune. Checked November 21, 2026.
- College Football Playoff bubble after Week 12, CBS Sports. Checked November 21, 2026.
- How social media reacted to BYU's 3OT win over Kansas, Deseret News. Checked November 21, 2026.
- Bouncing back against Baylor is the task for Bear Bachmeier after the Utah loss, Deseret News. Checked November 21, 2026.
- BYU missed out on Big 12 title game, but still produced a most unexpected story, Deseret News. Checked November 21, 2026.
- 3 takeaways from BYU's Big 12 championship game loss to Texas Tech, Deseret News. Checked November 21, 2026.
- BYU's 11-1 run checks boxes for Big 12 title game, Deseret News. Checked November 21, 2026.
- Monson: BYU won in triple overtime. It might still feel like a loss, The Salt Lake Tribune. Checked November 21, 2026.
- BYU football scores and box scores, 2026 season, Sportradar (via Claude sports data). Checked November 21, 2026.